نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
Constitutional amendment unfolds within a tension between preserving the continuity of a legal order and responding to demands for justice. This article asks under what conditions institutional continuity can contribute to the normative legitimacy of constitutional change. It distinguishes normative legitimacy from legal validity and sociological acceptance and employs a normative-analytical method together with context-sensitive functional comparison. Elements of gradual reform in Edmund Burke’s thought are reconstructed in dialogue with discursive legitimacy, non-domination, and multidimensional justice. The resulting Continuity–Justice Index comprises three distinct dimensions: institutional continuity, procedural justice, and distributive consequences. Its application to Ireland, Chile, and Iran shows that compliance with amendment procedures, the quality of participation, and the outcome of a popular vote must not be conflated. A positive referendum result does not by itself establish procedural justice, just as a negative result does not prove its absence. In Iran, the current design of Article 177 provides a strong framework for formal continuity. The 1989 revision, however, must be assessed separately because the 1979 Constitution contained no express amendment rule; its institutional continuity was therefore mixed and contestable. Articles 4 and 177 give binding legal force to Islamic norms and delimit the scope of constitutional revision without immunising all amendable institutional arrangements from criticism. The proposed index is not a final decision-making authority; it is an analytical device for separating the dimensions of constitutional legitimacy and subjecting each to reasoned evaluation.
کلیدواژهها English