Document Type : Original Article
Authors
1
Ph.D, in Criminal Law and Criminology, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
2
PhD Student in Higher Education Management, Faculty of Educational Sciences and Psychology, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran.
3
LLB Student. Faculty of Law and Political Science, University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran.
10.48315/qgl.2026.555788.1288
Abstract
Resolving issues within a legal system cannot rely solely on interpretive methods; rather, legal problems must be analyzed through policy-oriented approaches and methodologies. Since the concept of a “claim” in civil justice occupies a position relatively similar to that of “crime” in criminal justice, its empirical examination can provide the foundation for the development of “Disputology” as a field analogous to criminology. In this regard, drawing on insights from criminal justice policy, a case study was conducted based on 400 cases comprising 1,547 judicial decisions related to “money claim” lawsuits—the most frequent type of civil lawsuit. The study employed systematic content analysis with a descriptive–analytical approach. The selected cases were chosen randomly from various judicial districts, and four categories of data were extracted and analyzed: (1) the value of claims and judgments, (2) case outcomes, (3) appeals and reversals, and (4) the origins of the monetary claims. To better understand the situation of Iran’s justice system, the extracted data were compared with similar claims in several common-law jurisdictions. The results indicate that most claims for money in Iran involve relatively small financial values, have limited rates of settlement, and a substantial proportion of judgments are appealed. Moreover, a significant portion of monetary claims originates from transactions involving goods and services. In the compared jurisdictions, small claims constitute a considerable share of civil cases; however, a large proportion of judgments are issued by default judgment without substantive proceedings, while overall settlement rates are generally higher. The findings demonstrate that employing a criminal justice policy framework can enable a new form of research within the civil justice system—an essential requirement for addressing its problems. The development of this approach in civil justice policy-making requires the establishment of institutional structures for policy-oriented research both inside and outside the judiciary.
Keywords