An Analysis of Jurisprudential Evidences for the Recovery of Blocked Assets and Litigation in International Tribunals.

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Ayatollah Boroujerdi University, Boroujerd, Iran
2 PhD in Jurisprudence and Fundamentals of Islamic Law, Ferdowsi University of Mashhad, Mashhad, Iran
10.48315/qgl.2026.533483.1247
Abstract
The freezing of assets belonging to Islamic states within the international system has presented Imāmī jurisprudence with an apparent conflict between the permissibility of istinqādh (reclaiming property from a belligerent non-Muslim, kāfir ḥarbī) and the obligation to uphold international treaties. This research, aiming to provide a jurisprudential-legal framework for the recovery of these assets, employs a descriptive-analytical method and qualitative content analysis of Imāmī jurisprudential sources to analyze the evidences of this conflict. The findings indicate that this apparent contradiction can be resolved by distinguishing between "primary rulings" (al-aḥkām al-awwaliyyah) and "secondary rulings" (al-aḥkām al-thānawiyyah). The primary ruling permitting istinqādh is definitively confined to a "belligerent non-Muslim in an active state of war." In the contemporary context, it is rendered inapplicable due to the predominance of secondary rulings arising from principles such as ʿahd (covenants/treaties), amān (security guarantee), and the necessity of avoiding wahn al-Islām (the disparagement of Islam). Accordingly, the application of istinqādh in the modern world is legitimized through a hierarchical framework of measures: primarily, peaceful measures such as litigation in international tribunals, based on principles like nafī sabīl (negation of foreign domination) and the impermissibility of the loss of rights; and, in the event of treaty violation or aggression by the opposing party, defensive measures and countermeasures based on the rules of taqāṣṣ (retaliation), muqābalah bi-l-mithl (reciprocity), and jihād difāʿī (defensive struggle). Consequently, by presenting this dynamic doctrine, Imāmī jurisprudence offers the Islamic state a balanced path between passivity and unregulated aggression—one that emphasizes commitment to covenants while providing legitimate and potent means to defend the community's rights against economic predation.
Keywords